VNJ Volume 39 (3) June 2024 | Page 6

Restrictive covenants in employment contracts

In an employment contract , a restrictive covenant is a clause stating that an employee cannot take certain actions that are in competition with the employer ' s business – this could apply during the term of the employment and / or once it ends . Restrictive covenants must be clear , specific and time-restricted to be enforceable . Even then , this area of law can be complex for employers and employees alike .

A restrictive covenant in a contract or terms and conditions of work is likely to be under a heading of ‘ restrictive covenants ’ or ‘ post-termination restrictions ’. It could state that , for example , once an employee has left the organisation they are not allowed to approach the employer ' s customers for business or work for a competing business within 10 miles . Such a clause should also state how long the restriction lasts – usually this would be 3 – 6 months .
Employees will usually have to adhere to these restrictions if they appear in their agreed employment contract . This includes restrictions in any other agreed documents , such as a deal to settle a dispute with an employer . However , if there are no restrictions in the agreed documents , an employee will be free to work wherever they like at the end of their employment .
If an employee does not have a written contract , it would be difficult for their employer to successfully claim that a verbal agreement included a restriction . Restrictive covenants must be precise and specific , so it is unlikely that an employee would be expected to adhere to one that is not written down .
In additional to being specific , restrictive covenants must also be reasonable . No matter what is in an employment contract , an employer cannot stop an employee taking a new job unless it could lose the employer money .
Therefore , it might be considered reasonable to restrict an employee from taking customers to their new employer when they leave , or to restrict them from starting a competing business in the local area . However , a restriction on an employee might not be considered reasonable if :
• it lasts for more than 6 months
• it encompasses areas where the employer does not do business , for example , stating a whole region but the employer ' s customers are from only one town
• it applies to jobs in businesses that do not compete with the employer , such as preventing an employee taking any other sales job , even if that job entails selling entirely different products
• it means the employee would not be able to find a new job at all .
If there is a restrictive covenant in your employment contract and you are changing jobs , there are a number of factors to consider – and potentially negotiate – with your old and new employers .
Negotiating with an old employer
You might be able to persuade your old employer to ignore a restriction , or at least make it shorter in duration . To enforce a restriction , they would need to go to court to prove the restriction is reasonable . This is time-consuming and can be expensive , so they might prefer to compromise .
You could start by explaining to your old employer why you think the restriction should not apply . Explain why your new job will not harm their business , as they might have misunderstood your new job or place of work .
6 Veterinary Nursing Journal